Plus, Alex Goldman reveals a dark, personal secret.Perfect Crime and We Didn't Start The Fire originally ran in January 2016 and May 2019, respectively.Tweet from the episode:Showering is classist now. STEVEN CROWDER: Have you been outside? But if they had watched Steven Crowder's videos in their entirety, they would understand that the offensive stuff was just a small percentage of what actually appears in the videos. In the midst of a historic election, Alex, PJ and Emmanuel talk to our listeners. But the thing that really surprised me about this conversation was that Andrea said YouTube didn't want to take these videos down because the context of the videos mattered. So it's not just him making jokes, it's like him making homophobic and racist jokes and then four other grown men laughing at them and jumping in. And this is how previously obscure conspiracy theorists, racists, etcetera suddenly started getting a ton of new traffic from YouTube. (ALEX: Mm-hmm) And then it might push you to a Ted Talk about synthesizers, and then it might push you to a, you know, a performance by um…, KEVIN: Herbie Hancock. How It Works ① Brainstorm. So when Carlos posts a new Strikethrough episode, often there’s a rebuttal from Steven. For letting me know about comedy - I won’t–I don’t know what I would do without you Mr. Lispy Queer from Vox. It starts with this video that he posts, one that felt completely innocuous and uncontroversial when he posted it. And if Steven Crowder gets demonetized, it doesn't matter because he's able to sell merch to the- to this now loyal fan base of customers that YouTube found for him. STEVEN CROWDER: The Gay Vox sprite is wrong! Hundreds of reply-all responses followed the original alert, many of them instructing others not to reply all, then answers from an occasional troll would trigger a further deluge. But when someone with a big enough following gets harassed and they go public about it, usually it’s dealt with pretty quickly. When I click "reply all" on a mail that is sent to me I see that Outlook also adds my own e-mail to the To field. Carlos Maza supporters were mad because Steven Crowder hadn’t been banned from YouTube. Hate speech is almost always coupled with some other demand or criticism of the target. CARLOS: Yeah. Wiccan life. Or, an anti-affirmative action lecture could lead you to a video about eugenics. ANDREA: And if that exact video had been uploaded to YouTube, that video would have violated our policies. He has millions of subscribers, the alt-right loves him, conservative politicians love him. And he can say buy my mug, buy my socialism is for fags shirts. Carlos Maza started posting videos on YouTube, and ran afoul of a guy who reminded him of his high school bullies. Looking forward to listening to this one on my commute home today. Learn from John ColpittsListen to Song Exploder, a huge inspiration for this episode. ALEX: That little box – that’s the engine that drives YouTube. ALEX: What Andrea’s talking about here is that montage that Carlos posted to Twitter of all the nasty things that Steven Crowder said about him. ALEX: Every design choice and every engineering choice that YouTube was making at this point was supposed to try and get people to watch videos longer. And Steven Crowder supporters were mad because he’d been demonetized. Ik vraag me ook wel eens af waarom dat toch is. My- my–my parents are freaked out, I haven't been staying at my apartment, for obvious reasons. Scenario: You're on an email thread that no longer applies to 70 percent of the recipients because they're not going to dinner, participating in the blood drive or hoping to make out with someone they work with. Reply All is hosted by PJ Vogt and me Alex Goldman. You can also follow Saidu on Twitter @SaiduTTJ. When YouTube started out, it began with this idea that was very utopian -- it was going to be a forum for free speech, a marketplace of ideas. ALEX: In 2016, YouTube hit their goal. We travel to Atlanta to find out what’s going on, in our thorniest Super Tech Support yet.This story originally aired in February 2016.Further ReadingKashmir Hill's story about Mike and Christina. Each user is using softphone. And it's one that, that costs us meaningful access to free speech because who in their right mind would want to talk about politics if they knew that every time they did, they'd get called a lispy queer? So instead of selecting based on views it was going to try to optimize watch time. Home / Series / Reply All (Podcast) / Aired Order / Season 2019 / Episode 145 #145 Louder English. But Carlos can’t shake the feeling that what he’s doing is not completely safe. In the midst of a historic election, Alex, PJ and Emmanuel talk to our listeners. He asked YouTube to intervene, and then things got extremely complicated. Why? And they're the kind of videos that Carlos would've loved to have watched growing up. Uber strike. And I- I–I don’t know–looking back I'm like, “What was I thinking?” But I came out in high school like in the middle of all that. I waste a lot of time blocking abusive Crowder fanboys, and this shit derails your mental health. He asked YouTube to intervene, and then things got extremely complicated. ALEX: It wasn’t just Carlos, a lot of people that I talked to told me that YouTube thinks of demonetization as a serious punishment, when many times, it just isn’t. Our intern is Emily Rostek. We've updated our Terms of Service. Listen Now June 27, 2019 #144 Dark Pattern . CARLOS: The way that Crowder's show is set up, it's like him and four of his friends in the studio. Because when those people break the rules, or tiptoe around them -- they do so knowing that they have power. KEVIN ROOSE: I’ve been fascinated with YouTube for a longtime, and like the recommendations algorithm specifically. Reply All’s “The Case of the Missing Hit,” which follows the story of a man with the Evan Olson song “So Much Better” stuck in his head, is an instant classic. ALEX; Oh my god there is nothing I’d rather you do. ALEX: Landing on Steven Crowder’s radar is a huge deal. STRIKETHROUGH: And then made clear how bonkers this whole thing was. And what YouTube has done is basically say, “Hey if you want to get away with hate speech on the platform just make sure you sandwich it between, you know, 10 minutes of political nonsense that isn't that. Squarespace – The easiest way to create a beautiful website, portfolio or online store. ALEX: In 2015, YouTube makes another huge change to their algorithm. Matt Lieber is watching one of your favorite videos from childhood and finding that it still holds up. Do not reply all. STEVEN CROWDER: The global warming alarmists are out in flock, you’ve seen these people. ALEX: This may sound innocuous, but the consequences of this algorithm change were huge. Louder is part of Future plc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. And this week, he brings us a story about a mysterious recording that has been popping up on government hotlines for years. Carlos Maza. ANDREA: I mean and, and it was directed at a lot of different people. Learn More, This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. When I was in high school people would say, “Hey faggot get out of the way.” Or, “Hey faggot shut up.” And the primary intent of that speech was to get me to do something. Reply all is like anything else: with every use it decreases in value. ALEX: The thread hits a nerve, it gets retweeted over 20,000 times. Reply All: #145 Louder July 11, 2019 10:25 AM - Subscribe Carlos Maza started posting videos on YouTube, and ran afoul of a guy who reminded him of his high school bullies. Fact-checking by Michelle Harris. It’s a story about YouTube blindly and ambitiously focusing on one very specific part of the site. All rights. I asked Carlos what he thought about this, and he found the idea really naive. And nothing happens. There is a part of my brain that's like, “I'm going to quit and go teach to Dungeons & Dragons to kids for the rest of my life.” And that sounds really appealing, but my honest answer is I don't know. Hi DrKRM15, To better assist you with this concern, I would like to know if you're pertaining to Outlook app or the built-in Mail app for iOS. Everyone who agreed with Carlos was enraged by this decision. Andrea Faville. ALEX: What Steven Crowder was doing seemed to pretty clearly violate YouTube’s Rules. It’s a site that makes life really easy for people like Steven Crowder at the expense of people like Carlos. KEVIN: Right so there’s sort of a long story here. ALEX: Remember this was all happening before YouTube had even rendered a verdict -- before they’d indicated they might punish Steven Crowder in any way. KEVIN: I mean, you’ve already seen congressional hearings about anti-conservative bias, you know, executives from social media companies have been dragged to Capitol Hill to explain themselves. Saidu Tejan Thomas Jr. shares a story from his new podcast, Resistance.Find more episodes of Resistance here: https://open.spotify.com/show/02JzQLXpqTtViFUGQjRkj3?si=PvQrGlB7QEuf0AcgsGklHg&utm_source=copy-link To get more information about the show, follow the show's Instagram page: @resistanceshow. ALEX: Carlos grows up, he becomes one of these YouTube people that he admired as a kid. A part of the site that on its face doesn’t seem like it would have anything to do with Carlos Maza or Steven Crowder. They told him quote, “Our teams spent the last few days conducting an in-depth review of the videos flagged to us and while we found language that was clearly hurtful, the videos as posted don’t violate our policies.”. STEVEN CROWDER: Thank you! Online vertaalwoordenboek. In fact, he says that the real bully here -- is Carlos. KEVIN: Like- it would–it would eventually get to Gangnam Style because that was like the most popular video on the website. Obviously not me, but multiple people have sent links to that pornography to my bosses at Vox and cc'ed me. But then, a day later YouTube surprised everybody by saying -- actually -- we are going to punish Steven Crowder. People asked me how this story ends, I'm gonna have to say and, and then nothing. Steven Crowder has almost 4 million subscribers, who hang onto his every word. And that is not the Youtube that he grew up on -- it’s changed over time. STEVEN CROWDER: Ben Shapiro how are you sir? This kind of thing happens online a lot. Further Reading: Carlos Maza's video series Strikethrough Mark Bergen on how toxic videos became more common on YouTube Megan Farokhmanesh's article about Google's LGBTQ employees and their … Recipients can also download, edit, and transmit any attached files in whatever way they see fit. And it was just him repeating all of the slurs that he's used in the past in this sort of faux apology in order to be able to just say them all in a row again. if I didn't lose, I like lost a lot in the process. ALEX: So they finally kind of came back and demonetize these videos. De term reply komt ook voor binnen sociale media. Is it enough? Strangers keep coming to Mike and Christina’s house looking for their stolen cell phones. ALEX: YouTube was a free website hosting an infinite amount of video, which gets really expensive. We didn’t start the— LxDx (@wokestbloke) May 10, 2019, A small town in Wisconsin becomes the site of a completely unprecedented experiment. ANDREA: From various different videos that Crowder uploaded. I do want to go back to like the supercut video for a second. STEVEN CROWDER: Mexican, Gay, Latino there at Vox... ALEX: The guidelines specifically prohibit quote: “Content that is deliberately posted to humiliate someone OR content that makes hurtful and negative personal comments/videos about another person.”. And the 17 year old kid who tried to save the day. STRIKETHROUGH: Look at what happened after Trump tweeted that Obama had wiretapped his phones at Trump tower. So he takes that video and posts it to Twitter with a statement. That it takes this happening to someone to get a big corporation that claims to give a shit about queer people to even attempt to do the bare minimum to protect us from abuse. Because their whole brand is that what they’re saying is dangerous, and the establishment wants to shut them up. And it made life for Carlos really hard. As a kid, he was chubby and shy, and he had a very hard time fitting in at the all-boys Catholic high school that his parents sent him to. He asked YouTube to intervene, and then things got extremely complicated. ALEX: [stumble.] STEVEN CROWDER: [music] Vox released this video talking about the importance and the validity of liberal satire in the time of Donald Trump. Other movies and shows are super loud with even louder commercial. And that's not what YouTube's decided to do and I'm just wondering what the calculus was in making that decision. He asked YouTube to intervene, an… It’s a way to make a point without drawing blood, but let’s get into their reasoning, and they pivot to something that is oh so expected. Listen to Brian Dean's version of We Wish You a Merry Christmas, A new podcast about scary movies for people who are too scared to ever watch them. Except -- they don’t. ALEX: What was your like first experience being bullied? What if they have like my personal information? And the reason I wanted to is because to me personally, what Steven Crowder did like his behavior was like racist, homophobic. People are enjoying them. CARLOS: It was just like a- my–the high school I went to was like really, had like an out of control bullying and homophobia problem. 187 EpisodesProduced by GimletWebsite "'A podcast about the internet' that is actually an unfailingly original exploration of modern life and how to survive it." KEVIN: So if you were watching like an obscure synthesizer tutorial, it might push you to a more popular synthesizer tutorial. He asked YouTube to intervene, and then things got extremely complicated.Further Reading:Carlos Maza's video series StrikethroughMark Bergen on how toxic videos became more common on YouTubeMegan Farokhmanesh's article about … ANDREA: And um, so what our harassment policy does is it looks for videos where the primary purpose of the video is to harass, insult, bully another person or to incite harassment of that person. The president is tweeting about how people can’t find him on Twitter, um, because Twitter is biased against conservatives. And the purpose of that video, if viewed, would have been clearly to harass another person. In the meantime, Steven Crowder uses Carlos’s complaint to cast himself as a martyr -- an innocent guy under the thumb of left wing censorship. Think of any thought you've been wanting to share this week, personal story, commentary of recent events... ② Record After this whole dustup took place, Steven Crowder made a video where he basically, it was his quote unquote apology video. He asked YouTube to intervene, and then things got extremely complicated. Hi all, I'm using CUCM 7.1.3 and 2811 with FXO port as MGCP gateway. Together, they want to find out if it’s possible to become a person who enjoys fear.This week, The Exorcist.LinksHow Did This Get Made? And then, in April of 2017, just two months after he started Strikethrough his fears come true. That most people only saw the supercut of insults. Alex investigates. Use the offer code “REPLY” to get 10% off your first purchase. Carlos Maza started posting videos on YouTube, and ran afoul of a guy who reminded him of his high school bullies. Reply All. tolerated it. NL:reply. ALEX: Do you regret having posted that thread? Producer Emmanuel Dzotsi investigates.Additional Reading:Noni's petition to reform the film department at UNC: https://www.change.org/p/patricia-parker-racism-within-the-screenwriting-minor?recruiter=17176211&utm_source=share_petition&utm_medium=copylink&utm_campaign=tap_basic_shareMilly Tamarez' podcast, "All Dick is Trash": https://open.spotify.com/show/4eREYSWtBckafqqobfP42u?si=6TrZ8EfESpqiTwEF0_l_ggAnnika Neklason's article on Civil War Conspiracies in The Atlantic: https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2020/05/conspiracy-theories-civil-war/612283/, Just for fun, a guy and his friends record a Christmas song in his Living room. This January, YouTube tried to fix some of this -- they tweaked the algorithm so that it stopped recommending flat earth videos or anti-vaxxer videos. STEVEN: I’m doing alright, so I never know how to broach this subject... ALEX: Around the same time, YouTube came up with this other innovation to keep people on the site longer, which is after you finished a video another video, recommended to you based on what you'd watched, would start playing automatically. Like dicks. They tell Carlos they’re looking into it, and then they go silent. ALEX GOLDMAN: ALEX: How did you feel when you saw it? They’re doing everything they can to harass him. Reply All. 4.68. add rating. And so, they tweaked the recommendation algorithm so that it favored longer videos and the people who created them. Our editor is Tim Howard. ‎Show Reply All, Ep #145 Louder - Jul 11, 2019 ‎Carlos Maza started posting videos on YouTube, and ran afoul of a guy who reminded him of his high school bullies. Stuff like short sketches where he would play characters. He asked YouTube to intervene, and then things got extremely complicated. Emmanuel tries to figure out where this recording is coming from and who's putting it there. STEVEN CROWDER: Even his hand movement in fast motion is gay... CARLOS: I looked to see if YouTube had any kind of policy that could protect me from this kind of thing, and that's when I realized that YouTube had not just an anti-harassment and anti-bullying policy, but also an anti-hate speech policy, a–which was news to me. Um… When you were getting bullied in high school and you would tell the teachers, what would they say? ... Replay, Rebound - Live In Deutschland. to answer: “'I don't know,' he replied” antwoorden 1 an answer: “'I don't know,' was his reply” antwoord 2 the act of answering: “What did he say in reply (to your question)?” antwoord What if they have my family's stuff?” I don't know how to defend myself at all. Faced with an impossible choice, one man goes live on instagram. And it signals to queer people or people of color that if you want to participate in political discussions on YouTube that part of the price you have to pay is being willing to tolerate that we're going to get called a lispy queer or get made fun of for how we speak and how we act. ALEX: But just to back up. So the overall time that people spent on YouTube would be the thing that factored into the algorithm. BTSMAP OF THE SOUL : 7Released on: 2020-02-21Auto-generated by YouTube. Carlos Maza started posting videos on YouTube, and ran afoul of a guy who reminded him of his high school bullies. And like everyone in my family had to like change their passwords. The problem is that the internet looks way more like a high school than it does like some kind of free speech utopia. Plus, Alex volunteers for a risky and strange experiment. After the break--how YouTube’s predicament can be traced back to Gangnam style, yes, Gangnam style. And this is yet another giant company trying to lean on this channel, your channel, and the content that you've created. Like it's, it's bullshit. ALEX: Are you going to keep making videos? CARLOS: And then when I realized that he was making a lot of comments about my, um, voice and sexual orientation and ethnicity, my second feeling was just like a tremendous amount of embarrassment. Also visit Mailchimp’s new non-profit online store Freddieand.co. And this is a war, I want to make sure that everyone understands, we will fight to the absolute bitter end both legally and publicly. I've tried to increase the volume of softphone to maximum and increase the volume of headset to maximum. All rights except for copy and print. We’re produced by Sruthi Pinnamaneni, Phia Bennin, Damiano Marchetti, Anna Foley, Jessica Yung, and Emmanuel Dzotsi. He asked YouTube to intervene, and then things got extremely complicated.Further Reading:Carlos Maza's video series StrikethroughMark Bergen on how toxic videos became more common on YouTubeMegan Farokhmanesh's article about Google's LGBTQ employees and their reaction to the company's policy decisionsKevin Roose's "The Making of a YouTube Radical". Read only. I tried removing and adding the account again, deleting the pst file on computer, uninstalling and reinstalling Office 2016, nothing worked. Further Reading: Carlos Maza's video series Strikethrough. Carlos Maza started posting videos on YouTube, and ran afoul of a guy who reminded him of his high school bullies. (laughter) Now he could be a tranny, your Honor! Further Reading: Carlos Maza's video series Strikethrough Mark Bergen on how toxic videos became more common on YouTube Megan Farokhmanesh's article about Google's LGBTQ employees and their … Because back then it was just like a searchable America’s Funniest Home Videos. Carlos Maza started posting videos on YouTube, and ran afoul of a guy who reminded him of his high school bullies. Carlos is angry because he feels like Youtube has become a place where abuse is just a fact of life. Volume control is unbelievably bad. Special thanks this week to Claire Stapleton, Megan Farokhmanesh, Chris Stokel-Walker, Mark Bergen, Dieter Bohn. All their executives were sort of obsessed with this billion hours number. When there is incoming call to softphone, the user complain that the sound is small. Stream #145 Louder by Reply All from desktop or your mobile device Specifically, if the email is part of a mass message, all the recipients probably don’t need to receive a copy of your question to the sender. They’re telling him that they know where he lives, where his family lives. ALEX: So the reason I got in touch is because I was interested in talking about YouTube's moderation sort of in the wake of the Steven Crowder Carlos Maza blow up. And there were a lot more sitdown interviews with people like James O’Keefe and Gavin McInnes. KEVIN ROOSE: So YouTube in 2012, decided to make a sort of fundamental change in the way that their algorithms worked. Reply-All Don’ts. STEPHEN COLBERT: Right wing radio host and unlicensed gynecologist Mark Levin. Learn More. If you are experiencing any problems with this extension or have questions or suggestions for the developer, please fill out the form. Hello, My team is used to other chat programs such as Glip or Skype which usually pop-up a window when a message is sent, or send a loud ding so you know to check it. By Philip Wilding . The press is working to change that. From: Reply All 1 0 about 1 year ago Comedians all covered it basically the same way, they said it was baseless, pointed out that it came from a fringe conspiracy theorist. Because if a YouTube user was watching a video that leaned towards extreme viewpoints, Youtube would then recommend a video that was even more extreme. Go back and see the other crossword clues for Washington Post December 8 2020. discussing and debating the ideas in those videos. Great post and funny title. Reply All: #145 Louder July 11, 2019 10:25 AM - Subscribe Carlos Maza started posting videos on YouTube, and ran afoul of a guy who reminded him of his high school bullies. The story of an election in America where everything went wrong -- bribery, hacking, ballot-stuffing. This week — a new technology falls into the wrong hands.This episode originally aired in January, 2016.Pope Brock's book, Charlatan Penny Lane's documentary, Nuts! I'm the head of corporate communications for YouTube. What does that mean to you? There will always be monsters in the world. Also, I'd like to confirm if the Reply All button still appears even though the email is for one recipient only. This episode originally aired in December 2018.Further Reading:A Better Mount Pleasant vs Let's Make A Better Mount PleasantJournalist Larry Tabak's series on Foxconn in WisconsinEconomist David Merriman's paper on the type of financing used by Mount PleasantJournalist Brian Merchant's book which includes a visit to Foxconn campus in China. See, you’re using an adjective as part of a sentence to describe why that’s the case. It seemed tailormade to victimize Carlos Maza and to marshal Steven Crowder’s fans to like harass him and humiliate him which is exactly what they did. And so any action that youTube takes, risks coming off as censorship. More than three years later, he walks into a grocery store and hears that song playing. It's, it's not an anti-harassment policy, it's an instruction manual for how to harass. They included some offensive language but it was actually a much longer political debate. Go back and see the other crossword clues for Washington Post December 8 2020. 1. Stream #145 Louder by Reply All from desktop or your mobile device Vaak is er ook een functionaliteit ‘reply to all’ (allen beantwoorden), waarbij een kopie van de reactie naar de andere ontvangers van het e-mailbericht waarop men reageert wordt gestuurd. CARLOS: It feels mind numbing to argue this because it feels like arguing that the sky is blue or that gravity exists. Our ad music is by Build Buildings. That just being himself, an out gay man in front of this big group of people, is going to somehow get him in trouble. « Reply All #145 Louder 2019-07-11. Some shows and movies are extremely quiet so the TV or sound bar has to be extremely loud just to barely hear the show or movie and then the commercials come on at full blast. Mark Bergen on how toxic videos became more common on YouTube, Megan Farokhmanesh's article about Google's LGBTQ employees and their reaction to the company's policy decisions, Kevin Roose's "The Making of a YouTube Radical". ALEX: Andrea said that YouTube had taken lumps. It was just a ton of getting called a fag, being zip tied to my chair, (ALEX: groan) people would steal my bookbag, and like flip it inside out, and then draw a penis on it with chalk. ALEX: Carlos Maza grew up in Miami. Read More Free Trial Now. Does it mean anything? Reply All 187 Episodes Follow Share. my life sort of miserable. An email storm (also called a reply allpocalypse) is a sudden spike of "reply all" messages on an email distribution list, usually caused by a controversial or misdirected message.Such storms can start when even one member of the distribution list replies to the entire list at the same time in response to an instigating message. ALEX: Steven Crowder is actually a great example of this — when he started making videos in 2009, they were mostly like under five minutes. ALEX GOLDMAN: From Gimlet this is Reply All. ALEX: If I can jump in for just a minute. But the problem is they did it at least in part by letting all these sort of fringe voices flourish on their site. When you send an email in Outlook, your recipient can reply, reply all, forward, print, or attach that message to another message. This week, we call people across the world. ALEX: But around 2015, his videos ballooned to like 30, sometimes 60 minutes. ALEX: So the video goes up, and very quickly he realizes that another YouTuber has made a response video to it, this very, very popular YouTuber named Steven Crowder. Podcast, This week, we rebroadcast two of our favorite Super Tech Supports. Hosted by PJ Vogt, Alex Goldman and Emmanuel Dzotsi from Gimlet. Three years after Alex Goldman traveled to India to investigate a scammy call center, he gets a tip that makes him question everything he learned in his first trip.Long Distance Part ILong Distance Part IIAkash's YouTubeAkash's podcast episode. And when he watches it, it’s obvious to him that this is not ok. I wanted to ask YouTube how they’d come to their decision, and so I asked them for an interview. I’m Alex Goldman. KEVIN: I think that they fear political backlash if they start banning people because–. And they do that by tweaking the algorithm in a whole bunch of different ways. And PJ helps someone who saw a Tinder profile with a photo of a stranger that was taken in their own apartment.FURTHER READINGEvery Little Thing's latest episode: Essential Workers Call InAlisa Libby's "Maniacal Smile" Website. So, if you want to like, understand what YouTube is you have to understand like how that little box works. They want people to spend one billion hours a day on YouTube. So like, a 9/11- was an-inside-job video could lead you to a moon-landing-was-a-hoax-video. Securing your messages with IRM. Reply all sometimes ends up like getting a lot of notifications from a facebook post and your email gets clogged with all the nonsense. You can listen to our show on Spotify or wherever you get your podcasts. ALEX: You said something to the effect of, “I lost.” Is that, Is that, is that like really how you feel? Because at the time, the way YouTube worked was that people would go there, they'd watch a video and they'd leave. Our theme song is by the mysterious Breakmaster Cylinder. I'm like, I'm like really mad. I wanted to know how that happened. Every email client gives you the ability to reply to a message by clicking either reply or reply all. But, on Youtube, Steven Crowder made video after video: CROWDER: It’s been brought to my attention that many of the comments, videos and overall tenor and tone of this program have been considered hurtful and offensive to many... Like this fake apology video which he says is aimed at everyone he’s ever offended, but it’s just an opportunity for him to take some more shots. Like watching Tyler Oakley and Hannah Hart do weird shit and just kind of be charming and gay while they did it, was like really important for me. Are the things Steven Crowder is saying about me really that bad? 1. Black people all across the US are receiving the world's weirdest form of reparations: Venmo payments from white people. When you finished one video generally you would just get recommended a more popular version of the thing you’d just watched. Carlos Maza started posting videos on YouTube, and ran afoul of a guy who reminded him of his high school bullies. He's made a ton of money now. BEN SHAPIRO: I’m doing ok how are you dude? If you're the only recipient of an email, it doesn't matter whether you click Reply or Reply All, but if you're one of the multiple recipients, it does make a difference.